Welcome to the third newsletter of the Inclusive Innovation Forum. The first and second roundtables and newsletters considered how founders of colour can access funding, the different paths they can follow, the barriers they face, and what can be done to unlock their potential.
In the third roundtable we focused on understanding the role of public policy and how it can support founders of colour. At The Entrepreneurs Network we will use these insights of this project to inform its policy work and lobbying efforts, including:
- Ongoing discussions with government departments;
- Engagement with policy makers outside government, e.g. the Labour Start Up Review
- Upcoming conversations with the British Business Bank;
- Scoping out a briefing paper to impact policy.
Roundtable Insights
The roundtable opened by summarising the findings from the Report of the Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities, which analysed different areas, including employment and enterprise. As Tony Sewell, Chair of the Commission on Race and Ethnic Disparities, said in his opening remarks: “There are disparities in terms of who gets money from venture capitalists for their startups, and these disparities are also rooted in peer groups and families."
There was agreement that a barrier for underrepresented communities to start an entrepreneurial journey is the lack of access to capital. Marquis Caines, partner at Diversity-X, explained this problem: “Typically, in the black community, we can not do family and friends rounds. When we try to leave the ideation stage, most of us do not even have the capital to develop the idea of a product, which is a necessary first step before approaching venture capitalists.”
It was suggested that this situation should be addressed by the government:
"Public policy, especially within the pre-seed investment space, should include more vehicles to promote more equitable access to capital." – Dama Sathianathan, Partner at Bethnal Green Ventures.
“I don’t think that mentoring and outreach is good enough, because the question is not how do we discuss ideas, but how do we turn the idea into a business.” – Ahana Banerjee, Founder & CEO of Clear.
Mark Neild of the University of Bristol said: “People from underrepresented communities often can’t access Start Up Loans because credit decisions are based on whether the applicants have money and if they can pay it back.” He believes that credit decisions should shift to be more about the prospects of the business rather than the founder's already existing wealth.
The discussion, additionally, revolved around whether entrepreneurship can be promoted by shifting mindsets and encouraging people to convert their day jobs into a business. Mark Neild thinks this may be particularly important for excluded groups that may not be able to access employment and may be better suited to selling directly to the public rather than selling their skills to an employer.
Another major topic of conversation was around if entrepreneurs should focus on selling to their own communities or look to expanding their market beyond them. Many of the attendees said that an advantage of selling to their own communities is that they understand what their specific needs are that have not been solved by others.
Moving on, the discussion covered the importance of promoting minority-lead accelerators and other organisations that provide startup support. More diverse organisations that support startups could be game-changing.
Eni Timi-Biu, Founder & Director, Create Your Table, said: “The opportunity to design and deliver programmes can be monopolised by quite a few organisations who often mirror some of the biases that exist in the entrepreneurship ecosystem.”
Ahana Banerjee, Founder & CEO of Clear stated some of the key institutional blocks for underrepresented founders:
- There are too few ethnic minority investors in senior positions (with decision-making power) at VC funds;
- Companies tackling problems faced by underrepresented founders are often built by those minorities. These areas may be less familiar or less well understood by most investors, resulting in even more unknowns and an increased perceived risk;
- Many investors will not respond to cold communication, thus, the ability to fundraise is often tied to one’s network. Most people in VC come from a finance, tech, or a startup background; these are also white male-dominated fields.
It was agreed that something has to be done to overcome those institutional barriers and this is something that the private sector can help with. “Corporate-led programmes such as the Morgan Stanley Multicultural Innovation Lab, which focuses on actively investing in improving access and opportunities for diverse founders, are critical. We find that there is a strong business imperative to invest in diverse founders, given the resilience and innovation they bring to the table” said Sanghamitra Karra, EMEA head of multicultural client strategy at Morgan Stanley.
Finally, it was agreed that it would be valuable to have a better evidence base to, as Tony Sewell put it “gain a better understanding of what works and use this as a model to move forward.”